Barney Greengrass: The Jewish New York Deli Experience

Food & Drink
April 22, 2012 10:55 pm

Finding a bagel and lox in this city is as easy as finding the sidewalk—but an excellent bagel and lox? That question will throw most New Yorkers into a heated argument.

The truth is, many of NYC’s Jewish food institutions like Zabar’s and Barney Greengrass all fetch their smoked salmon varieties from the same high-quality vendors. It’s the preparation of these items that makes the special few stand out.

Barney GreengrassBarney Greengrass Nova Scotia salmon bialyBarney Greengrass latkesBarney Greengrass Chopped herring salad sandwich, on a bialyBarney Greengrass pastrami salmonbarney greengrass Nova Scotia salmon scrambled with eggs and onions, on an "everything" bagel
Barney Greengrass
Barney Greengrass Nova Scotia salmon bialy

Nova Scotia salmon sandwich with cream cheese, tomato and onion on a bialy, $14

Barney Greengrass latkes

Four latkes with sides of sour cream and applesauce, $12.50

Barney Greengrass Chopped herring salad sandwich, on a bialy

Chopped herring salad sandwich, with tomato and onion on a bialy, $10

Barney Greengrass pastrami salmon

Pastrami salmon with a side of scrambled eggs with onions and an "everything" bagel, $16

barney greengrass Nova Scotia salmon scrambled with eggs and onions, on an

Nova Scotia salmon scrambled with eggs and onions, on an "everything" bagel, $15

The service is perhaps the reason Barney Greengrass has been around for a century. Nova Scotia salmon, lox, and Gravlox may be interchangeable anywhere else, but at Barney Greengrass, your waiter will spend as much time as necessary explaining the differences between the three to ensure your sandwich has the right proportion of smoky flavor and salty goodness. (For the record, you can’t go wrong with the three choices anyway.)

In addition to the heavy salmon/lox and egg items on the menu, the smoked fish are a highlight often overlooked during brunch-time in NYC but never in a Jewish deli. (Zabar’s takes its smoked fish seriously enough to make a YouTube video about it.) Barney Greengrass is famous for its sturgeon and has been featured on travel and eating shows for a decade. Its chopped herring salad sandwich ($10, pictured) was featured on The Food Network’s “The Best Thing I Ever Ate: At A Deli” with Alton Brown, and Anthony Bourdain is a fan of the chopped liver and the scrambled eggs with lox and onions (pictured, $15).

To name not-to-miss menu items would be a crime, so the best I can do is advise that you try a little of everything, from the meaty potato latkes to the bagel sandwiches and lox platters. Just be careful—it’s an addiction! Barney Greengrass’s most famous customers, including Alfred Hitchcock and Al Jolson, used to have his lox and sturgeon flown across the country. The store still fulfills mail orders…


Barney Greengrass is located at 541 Amsterdam Avenue, at 86th Street. Open Tues-Sun, 8:30am – 6pm. (To-go opens at 8am.)

Related posts:



Powered by Facebook Comments

This article was written by on Sunday, April 22, 2012 at 10:55 pm. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS feed. You can skip to the end and leave a response. Pinging is currently not allowed. Tags:

Leave a Reply

The Best Travel Instagrammers

March 15, 2013 0 comments

Here it is… We’ve been Instagramming since April 2011, and we’ve developed pretty strong feelings about our favorite traveling Instagrammers. We like to call this the “starter pack”—follow away!

Continue Reading →

Carnival in Trinidad Party Report

February 22, 2013 2 comments
Carnival in Trinidad Party Report

As promised, my coverage of Carnival in Trinidad continues. Below is my “Just Back From” post I penned for Fodor’s Travel that details the Carnival highlights, from whining, liming and feting to everything in between. Also, you can learn what exactly those Trinidadian English terms mean in the Fodor’s post linked here: Just Back From: Carnival in Trinidad I talked a bit about high-energy, have-to-move-your-body, soca music in the post. In the video below you can hear more of the […]

Continue Reading →

Food Tours and Experiences in Buenos Aires

November 13, 2013 0 comments
Food Tours and Experiences in Buenos Aires

There’s a long-awaited and much-welcomed gastronomic revolution happening in Buenos Aires at present, and locals and visitors alike are winning with dinner, lunch and every other bite. My post for Forbes details some of the best ways to get in on it with tours, a chef’s table event and if you’re in town at the right time, fairs and restaurant weeks. Buenos Aires For Foodies   Once regarded as a land for great steak and not much else when it […]

Continue Reading →

Art Classes for Beginners in NYC

January 6, 2014 2 comments
Art Classes for Beginners in NYC

Drawing and painting is a great wintertime hobby outside the typical hibernation routine, and NYC has a plethora of options. These three are my favorites for their attitude, and their relationship to the city and the art world.

Continue Reading →